ISSN 0869-6632 (Print)
ISSN 2542-1905 (Online)


For citation:

Poizner B. N. Charisma: replication of reception. Izvestiya VUZ. Applied Nonlinear Dynamics, 2004, vol. 12, iss. 1, pp. 80-95. DOI: 10.18500/0869-6632-2004-12-1-80-95

This is an open access article distributed under the terms of Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC-BY 4.0).
Full text PDF(Ru):
(downloads: 0)
Language: 
Russian
Article type: 
Article
UDC: 
(8+14): 168+536.75

Charisma: replication of reception

Autors: 
Poizner Boris Nikolaevich, National Research Tomsk State University
Abstract: 

Why the phenomenon of charisma deserves attention of social synergetics? How thie sense of «charisma» concept has varied from antiquity up to now? What is а peculiarity of the charisma reception in Russian culture? How the midst of charismatic looks through the prism of nonlinear dynamics? The author aspires to answer similar questions proceeding from following thesis: propagation of the judgement about some person as a charismatic is typical case of a cultural pattern replication. The author bases on works on synergetics, theory of culture, sociology, linguistics, history of science, philosophical anthropology, examples of publicist style.

Key words: 
Acknowledgments: 
The author expresses his gratitude to S.V. Zeltsova for her advice on the sociology of the authorities. The work was supported by the Ministry of Education of the Russian Federation, grant № ГО2-1.4-377.
Reference: 

1. Neymark YuI. Ideal Game of People in Society. Izvestiya VUZ. Applied Nonlinear Dynamics. 2001;6:190.

2. Encyclopedia of mysticism. Saint Petersburg: Litera; 1996. 480 p.

3. Gritsanov AA, editor. The Latest Philosophical Dictionary. Comp. Minsk: Publishing house V.M. Skakun; 1998. 896 p.

4. Stepanov AM. Explanatory dictionary on esotericism, occultism and parapsychology. Moscow: Istoki, 1997. 336 p.

5. Nikitaev E. To the Origins of Power: the magical world. Centaur. 2002;29:2–17.

6. Weber M. Charismatic dominance. Sociological studies.1988;8:117.

7. Jung CG. Present and Future. In: Jung KG, Samuels E, Odaynik V, Hubback J. Analytical psychology. Moscow: Martis; 1995. P. 113.

8. Nikolaeva IYu. Personality and Power: search for research methodology. Methodological and historiographical issues of historical science. 1999;25:131.

9. Sosland A. Charisma of a Modern Politician and How to Create It. Logos.

Philosophical and literary journal. 1999;19(9):87 – 95.

10. Aimermacher K, Bordyugov G. Culture and power. Culture and power in the conditions of the communication revolution of the twentieth century: Forum of German and Russian researchers. Moscow: AIRO-XX, 2002; 7.

11. Pocheptsov GG. Imageology: theory and practice. Moscow: Refl-book; Kyiv: Wakler; 2000. 560 p.

12. Zemtsova SB, Negrul BB, Poizner BN. Power Elite in the Light of Synertics: towards the formulation of the problem. In: Proceedings of the Forth All-Russian scientific seminar «Self-organization of sustainable integrity in nature and society».

Tomsk; 2000. P. 138.

13. Stepanov YuS. Constants. Dictionary of Russian culture. Research experience. Moscow: Languages of Russian Culture; 1997. 824 p.

14. Poizner BN. On the Self-organization «Subject». Izvestiya VUZ. Applied Nonlinear Dynamics. 1996;4(4–5):149–158 (in Russian)

15. Zemtsova SB, Poizner BN. Charismatic in the Light of Synergetics. In: Abstracts оf thе Sixth Intern. School оf Chaotic Oscillations and Pattern Formation. 2-7 October 2001, Saratov, Russia. Saratov: College; 2001:69.

16. Toporov VN. Petersburg Text of Russian Literature. Saint Petersburg: Art-SPB; 2003. 616 p.

17. Lurie FM. Nechaev: Creator of Destruction. Moscow: Molodaya Gvardiya; 2001. 434 p.

18. Korolenko B.I. «If only Russia were alive!»: Unknown journalism. 1917-1921. Moscow: Agraf; 2002. 448 p.

19. Frezinsky BYa. The Fate of the Serapions. Portraits and scenes. Saint Petersburg: Academic project; 2003. 592 p.

20. Fleishman L. In the Grip of Provocation: operation «Trust» and Russian foreign press. Moscow: New lit. review; 2003. 328 p.

21. Sinyavsky AD. Literary process in Russia. Moscow: RSUH, 2003. 418 p.

22. Meletinsky EM. Tranformations of Archetypes in Russian classical literature (Space and Chaos, Hero and Antihero). In: Literary archetypes and universals. Moscow: RSUH; 2001. 136 p.

23. Skalkovsky K., comp. Russians’ Opinions about Themselves: a small reader for adults. M.: TERRA-Book Club, 2001. 304 p.

24. Sergeev CM., сomp. Nation and Empire in Russian thought of the Early Twentieth Century. Moscow: Skimen; 2004. 352 p.

25. Shpet GG. Essay on the Development of Russian Philosophy. In: Shpet GG. Essays. Moscow: Pravda; 1989. 602 p.

26. Agursky M. Ideology of National Bolshevism. Rostov-on-Don: YMCA-PRESS; 1980. 318 p.

27. Jansen M. Court without Trial. 1922 Show trial of the Socialist Revolutionaries. Moscow: Return, 1993. 272 p.

28. Tumarkin N. Lenin is alive! The cult of Lenin in Soviet Russia. Saint Petersburg: Academic project; 1997. 285 p.

29. Galkovsky D. Endless Dead End. Moscow: Samizdat, 1998. 708 p.

30. Panarin AS. Russian Intelligentsia in World Wars and Revolutions XX Century. Moscow: Editorial URSS, 1998. 352 p.

31. Cherkassky VB. Overturned into the Void. Moscow: Heritage, 1999. 232 p.

32. Yarov SB. The City Dweller as a Politician: revolution, war communism, NEP through the Eyes of Petrograd Residents. Saint Petersburg: Dmitry Bulanin; 1999. 320 p.

33. Zhidkov BS. Theater and Power. 1917-1927. «From freedom to conscious necessity». M.: Aletheya; 2003. 656 p.

34. Zhivov VM. Research in the Field of History and Prehistory of Russian Culture. Moscow: Languages of Slavic culture, 2002. 760 p.

35. Kantor VK. Russian European as a Cultural Phenomenon (Philosophical and Historical Analysis). Moscow: ROSSPEN, 2001. 704 p.

36. Hen YuV, ed The Idea of Death in the Russian mentality. Saint Petersburg: RKhGI, 1999. 304 p.; Mordovtseva TV. The Cult of the Dead in Ancient Rus'. Man.

2004;1:130.

37. Chistov KV. Russian Folk Utopia: Genesis and Functions of Socially Utopian legends. Saint Petersburg: Dmitry Bulanin, 2003. 544 p.

38. Geller L, Nike M. Utopia in Russia. Saint Petersburg: Hyperion, 2003. 312 p.

39. Discussion of the book by TI Oizerman «Marxism and Utopianism». Questions

philosophy. 2004;2:43.

40. Ilyina LL. Myths of Russia: thoughts of someone who lived during the era of Stalinism. Saint Petersburg: European House; 2003. 176 p.

41. Bilington J. Faces of Russia: suffering, hope and creation in Russian culture. Moscow: Logos, 2001. 248 p.

42. Rancourt-Laferriere D. Russia and Russians through the Eyes of America Psychoanalysis: in search of national identity. Moscow: Ladomir; 2003. 288 p.

43. Berlin I. History of freedom. Russia. Moscow: New lit. review, 2001. 544 p.

44. Nalimov VV. Temptation of Holy Rus': karmic theory of our culture. In: Nalimov VV. Temptation of Holy Rus'. On the verge of the third millennium. Tomsk-M.: Aquarius; 2002. P. 16.

45. Andreeva LA. Religion and Power in Russia Religious and Quasi-religious Doctrines as a Way of Legitimizing Political Power in Russia. Moscow: Ladomir, 2001. 253 p.

46. Kagarlitsky BYu. Restoration in Russia. Moscow: Editorial URSS; 2000. 376 p.

47. Geller M. Conversations about books; on «Freedom about freedom». Moscow: MUK; 2003. 224 p.

48. Lux L. Third Pum? Greek Reich? Third Way? Historical Essays about Russia, Germany and the West. Moscow: Moscow philosopher fund, 2002. 304 p.

49. Ilovaiskaya-Alberti IA. About Russia for Russia (Selected Publications of Recent Years). Moscow: Rudomino, 2002. 192 p.

50. Kordonsky SG. Crystal and Jelly: e-mails and articles 1989-2000. Moscow: Modest Kolerov and «Three Squares»; 2002. 224 p.

51. Rashkovsky EB Profession – Historiographer: materials for history Russian thought and culture of the twentieth century. Novosibirsk: Siberian Chronograph; 2001. 250 p.

52. Bibikhin VV. Another beginning. Saint Petersburg: Nauka, 2003. 430 p.

53. Ryklin M. Time of Diagnosis. Moscow: Logos, 2003. 328 p.

54. Rat MV. Militant Rationalism or «Reasonable» Rationality? Voprosy Filosofii. 2002;6:19–28.

55. Yarkova EH. Utilitarianism and the Dynamics of Civilization. Cultural Food Utilitarianism and Features of Its Manifestation in Russia. Civilization. Ascent and demolition: Structure-forming factors and subjects of civilization progress. Moscow, 2003. P. 290.

56. Savelzon O. Decision-making culture as a factor in Russia’s progress. Voprosy Filosofii. 2003;10:31–45.

57. Zolotonosov MN. Word and Body: sexual aspects, universals, interpretations of Russian cultural text of the 19th-20th centuries. Moscow: Ladomir, 1999. 830 p.

58. Pushkareva NL. «And these are evil, mortal sins...»: Love, eroticism and sexual ethics in pre-industrial Russia (X – first half of the 19th century). Moscow: Ladomir, 1999. 861 p.

59. Volkov SB. White Movement: Encyclopedia of the Civil War. Saint Petersburg: Neva; Moscow: OLMA-PRESS, 2002. 672 p.

60. The Case of Academician Nikolai Nikolaevich Luzin. Saint Petersburg: RKhGI, 1999. 312 p.

61. Esakov VD., Rubinin PE. Kapitsa, the Kremlin and Science. Vol. 1. Creation Institute of Physical Problems. M.: Nauka, 2003. 655 p.

62. Barber JD, Dzeniskevich AR, ed. Life and Death in Besieged Leningrad: historical and medical aspect. Saint Petersburg: Dmitry Bulanin; 2001. 268 p.

63. Rapoport YaL. At the Turn of Two Eras. The Doctors' Case of 1953. Saint Petersburg: Publishing house of the Pushkin Foundation; 2003. 280 p.

64. Makarov VG, Khristoforov VS. Passengers of the «Philosophical Steamer» (the Fate of the Intelligentsia Repressed in the Summer-autumn of 1922). Voprosy Filosofii. 2003;7:113–137.

65. Khazanov B. «Stalin is our military glory». New Journal. 2003;232:283.

66. Maksimenkov L. Essays on the Nomenklatura History of Soviet literature. Western Pilgrims at Stalin's throne (Feuchtwanger and Others). Voprosy Literatury. 2004;3-4:242.

67. Savitsky C. Underground (History and Myths of Leningrad Informal Literature). Moscow: New lit. review, 2002. 224 p.

68. Plutser-Sarno A. State Duma as folklore 67. Savitsky Cm. Underground (History and myths of Leningrad informal literature). M.: New lit. review, 2002. 224 p.

68. Plutser-Sarno A. State Duma as a folklore character. Logos. Philosophical lit. magazine 1999;9:65 – 79.

69. Aksyuchits V. Delusion of Genius: N.A. Berdyaev about Russia and communism. Historical and philosophical yearbook ‘2001. Moscow: Nauka, 2003. P. 324.

70. Geller L. Apology of Disorder. EI Zamyatin and Postmodernist Theory of Chaos. In: Evgeny Zamyatin and culture of the 20th century: Research and publications. Saint Petersburg: Publishing house of the Russian National Library, 2002. P. 156–167.

71. Ignatiev A. Chaos: the Invisible Border of Rationality. Blue sofa. Philosophical and theoretical journal. 2003;2:208.

72. Trubetskov DI. Oscillations and Waves for Humavitarians: A tutorial for universities. Saratov: College; 1997. 392 p.

73. Trubetskov D.I. The Color of Culture is not to Charles Snow (About Teaching the Course «Concepts of Modern Natural Science» at the Saratov State University). News of Saratov University: New series. 2003;3(2):66.

74. Kapitsa SP, Kurdyumov SP, Malinetsky GG. Synergetics Synergy and Forecasts Future. Moscow: Nauka, 1997. 285 p.

75. Ebeling V, Engel A, Feistel R Physics of Processes of Evolution. Moscow: Editorial URSS, 2001. 328 p.

76. Evin IA. Synergy of the Brain and Synergy of Art. Moscow: GEOS, 2001. 164 p.

77. Knyazeva EH, Kurdyumov SP. Foundations of Synergetics. Saint Petersburg: Aletheia; 2002. 414 p.

78. New in Synergetics: a look into the third millennium. Moscow: Nauka; 2002. 478 p.

79. Astafieva ON. Synergetic Approach to the Study of Sociocultural Processes: possibilities and limits. Moscow: MGIDA, 2002. 295 p.

80. Astafieva HE, ed. Synergetic paradigm. Human and society in Conditions of instability. Moscow: Progress-Tradition; 2003. 584 p.

81. Haken G. Secrets of nature. Synergetics: the science of interaction. Moscow: IKI, 2003. 320 p.

82. Lyubinskaya LN, Lepilin SV. Philosophical Problems of Time in Context of Interdisciplinary Research. Moscow: Progress-Tradition, 2002. 304 p.

83. Pugacheva EI, Solovyenko KN. Self-organization of Socio-economic Systems: Textbook. allowance. Irkutsk: Publishing house BGUEP, 2003. 172 p.

84. Barantsev RG. Synergetics in modern natural science. Moscow: Editorial YPCC, 2003. 144 p.

85. Weisman AD. Greek-Russian Dictionary. Moscow: Greco-Latin cabinet YuA Shichalina; 1991. 1370 p.

86. Vasmer M. Etymological Dictionary of the Russian Language. Vol. 4. Moscow: Progress, 1987. 864 p.

87. Benveniste E. Dictionary of Indo-European Social Terms. Moscow: Progress-Univers; 1995. 456 p.

88. Greiva P. Myths of Ancient Greece. M.: Progress, 1992. 624 p.

89. Cerderidi YuI, comp. Heritage of Hellas: Encyclopedic Dictionary. Krasnodar: Sov, Kuban; 1993. 496 p.

90. Superanskaya AV. The Name – through Centuries and Countries. Moscow: Nauka, 1990. 192 p.

91. Kirillina LV. Gallantry and Sensitivity in the Music of the 18th century. In: Goethe Readings – 2003. M.: Nauka, 2003. 263 p.

92. Bunimovich HT, Zharkova GG, Kornilova T.M., et al. Dictionary of Modern Concepts and Terms. Moscow: Republic, 2002. 527 p.

93. Glagolev SS. Grace. In: Christianity: Encyclopedic Dictionary. Vol. 3. Moscow: Bolshaya Ross. encyclopedia, 1995. 781 p.

94. Uvarov AS. Christian Symbolism. Symbolism of ancient Christian period. Moscow: UNIK; Saint Petersburg: Aletheya, 2001. 256 p.

95. Dyachenko G. Complete Church Slavonic Dictionary: reprint reproduction of the 1900 edition. Moscow: Publishing department of the Moscow Patriarchate; 1993. 1120 p.

96. Barsov NI. Christianity: In: Christianity: Encyclopedic Dictionary. Vol. 3. Moscow: Bolshaya Ross. encyclopedia, 1995. 671 p.

97. Belting H. Image and cult. Moscow: Progress-Tradition, 2002. 752 p.

98. Ryabushinsky VP. Old Believers and Russian religious feeling. Russian owner. Articles about the icon. Moscow – Jerusalem: Bridges, 1994. 240 p.

99. Strizhev AN, comp. Theology of the Image. Icon and icon painters. Moscow: Pilgrim, 2002. 464 p.

100. Yazykova N. «Behold, I create everything new»: icon in the twentieth century. Milano: La Casa di Matriona; 2002. 224 p.

101. Anarina NG. Sacred Physicality of a Japanese Artistic Object. In: Thing in Japanese culture. Moscow: Vostochnaya literature RAS; 2003. 262 p.

102. Molodyakova E.V. Thing in a Sacred Environment. In: Thing in Japanese culture. Moscow: Vostochnaya literature RAS; 2003. 262 p.

103. Mayer P. In space – time is here... The story of the Grail. M.: Enigma; 1997. 352 p.

104. Bethea D. The Embodiment of Metaphor: Pushkin, the life of a poet. Moscow: OGI, 2003. 256 p.

105. Gurevich AYa. «Time has become dislocated»: desecration of a deceased ruler. Odysseus. Man in history; 2003. Moscow: Nauka, 2003. 447 p.

106. Diamont M. Jews, God and History. Moscow: Image, 1994. 530 p.

107. Laitman M. Fruits of Wisdom (Kabbalah. Secret teaching). M.: Tree of Life; Kabbala.org.ru; 2002. 444 p.

108. Losev AF. Letter to BM Loseva from 03/11/1932. In: Losev AF. Life. Saint Petersburg: Komplekt;1993. P. 396.

109. «This is how the truth is tortured and crucified»: AF Losev in reviews OGPU. Source: Documents of Russian history. 1996. Bulletin 4. P. 115.

110. Kurganov E. Dostoevsky and the Talmud, or Strokes to the Portrait of Ivan Karamazov. Saint Petersburg: Zvezda, 2002. 144 p.

111. Katsis L. Father Pavel (Florensky), Lev of Modena and «SHISH» Alexey Kruchenykh. In: Katsis L. Russian eschatology and Russian literature. Moscow: OGI, 2000. P. 118.

112. Steinsaltz A, ed. Babylonian Talmud. Treatise of Bava Metzius. 1st chapter; Rus. lane and ed. 3. Moscow: Publishing house of the Russian Scientific Center «Kurchatov Institute», 1995. 344 p.

113. Batkin LM. European Man alone with Himself. Essays on cultural and historical foundations and limits of personal identity. M.: Russian. roc. humanist Univ., 2000. 1005 p.

114. Kurganov E. Russian proverbs and Talmud. Five studies. Saint Petersburg; Zvezda;2003. 104 p.

115. Militarev AYu. Embodied Myth: the «Jewish idea» in civilization. Moscow: Natalis, 2003. 256 p.

116. Pletneva EK. Biblia judaica et biblia christiana: about the possibility comparative hermeneutics. Odyssey. Person B of the story. Moscow: Nauka, 2003. P. 61.

117. Botstein L. Jews and modern times: about the role of Jews in German and Austrian cultures (1848-1938). Saint Petersburg: Belvedere, 2003. 464 p.

118. Khoruzhy SS. On the Phenomenology of Asceticism. Moscow: Publishing House for the Humanities literature; 1998. 352 p.

119. Papadimitriou G. Maimonidi and Palama about God. Moscow: Way; 2003. 120 p.

120. Burmistrov K, Vladimir Soloviev and Kabbalah. To the Formulation of the problem. Studies in the history of Russian thought: Yearbook for 1998. Moscow: OGI; 1998. P. 7.

121. Kurganov E, Mondry G. Vasily Rozanov and the Jews. Saint Petersburg: Academic project; 2000. 272 p.

122. Katsis L. Russian Eschatology and Russian Literature. Moscow: OGI; 2000. 656 p.

123. Katsis L, Shusharin D. «Then: the horror begins»: OBERIU Jacques religious phenomenon. In: Studies on the histories of Russian thought: Yearbook for 1997. Saint Petersburg: Aletheya, 1997. P. 134.

124. Katsis. L. Osip Mandelstam musk of Judaism. Yerusaeshm Gesharim; M.: Bridges of Culture; 2002. 598 p.

125. Bulgakov SH. Name: Sat. theological and journalistic articles, documents and comments. Vol. Moscow, 2003. 992 p.

126. Florensky PA. At the watersheds of thought. M.: Mysl, 1999. 1994–1999. Vol. 3. P. 2. 623 p.

127. Losev AF. Name: favorite works, translations, conversations, research, archival materials. Saint Petersburg: Aletheya, 1997. 618 p.

128. Khoruzhy SS. Name-glorification and Culture of the Silver Age: a phenomenon Moscow School of Christian Neoplatovism [Electronic resource]. Available from:

www.religion.russ.ru. https://www.religion.russ.ru.

129. Khoruzhy SS. Hesychasm as a Space of Philosophy. In: Khoruzhy S.S. About old and new. Saint Petersburg: Aletheya, 2000. P. 261–288.

130. Dal V. Explanatory Dictionary of the Living Great Russian language. Vol. 4. Moscow: Progress-Univers, 1994. 1620+XVII-+XII p.

131. Comos VP. Dictionary of Rare and Forgotten Words. Moscow: Humanite. IC «VLADOS», 1996. 784 p.

132. Rossman VI. Deconstruction of Deconstruction: the metaphysics of presence in Rays of the Star of David. Voprosy filosofii. 2001;10:57–72.

133. Ryklin M. Book before Book: signatures removed from Kafka and Benjamin J.

In: Benjamin W. Franz Kafka. M.: Ad Marginem, 2000. P. 7.

134. Conversations of Anatole France, collected by Paul Gsell. Moscow: State publishing house; 1923. 218 p.

134a. Ostroukhova EN, Kuvshinov FV. Nicknames of DN Kharms. In: «Strange» poetry and «strange» prose: a philological collection dedicated to 100th anniversary of the birth of NA Zabolotsky. Moscow: Fifth Country, 2003. P. 231.

135. Shmelev AD. Russian Language Model of the World. Moscow: Slavic languages culture; 2002. 224 p.

136. Arapova NS, Kimyagarova PS, Bash LM, Bobrova AV. Dictionary of Foreign Words: current vocabulary, interpretation, etymology. Moscow: Citadel; 1999. 336 p.

Received: 
03.09.2003
Accepted: 
14.05.2004
Published: 
20.06.2004