For citation:
Poizner B. N. Charisma: replication of reception. Izvestiya VUZ. Applied Nonlinear Dynamics, 2004, vol. 12, iss. 5, pp. 72-97. DOI: 10.18500/0869-6632-2004-12-5-72-97
Charisma: replication of reception
Why the phenomenon of charisma deserves attention of social synergetics? How the sense of «charisma» concept has varied from antiquity up to now? What is a peculiarity of the charisma reception in Russian culture? How the midst of charismatic looks through the prism of nonlinear dynamics? The author aspires to answer similar questions proceeding from following thesis: propagation of the judgement about some person as a charismatic is typical case of a cultural pattern replication. The author bases on works on synergetics, theory of culture, sociology, linguistics, history of science, philosophical anthropology, examples of publicist style.
In preceding parts of the paper characteristics of charisma as a psychological phenomenon starting in primeval society is done. Etymology of «charisma», meaning constants and variables of the word are shown. Contexts in which concept of charisma is used in Christianity, Judaism, East philosophy are touched. Some semantic peculiarities of the concept in Russian, French, English languages are noted. Interpretations of charisma in Shamanism, Christianity, modern cultural practice (the last is distinguished by vulgarization of the word) are compared. Concepts of charismatic and genius are
compared. Replication of human activity structures is interpreted as a dynamical aspect of culture and a mechanism of culture self-renewal.
Part 3
In third part non-linear interaction stages of the masses, charismatic and his promoters are described. The scheme known as «order out of chaos» and the concept of the replication are used. The suggested synergetic approach is applied to interpretation of soviet scholars’ perception of academician N. Marr and his «new doctrine оп language». An attitude to a charismatic is discussed as one of manifestation of the people spirit.
233. Lotman YuM. Clio at the crossroads. In: Lotman YuM. Selected articles in three volumes. Tallinn: Aleksandra; 1992. Vol. 1. P. 464–471.
234. Averintsev SS. «Skvoreshnits free citizens...». In: Vyacheslav Ivanov: the poet's path between worlds. St. Petersburg: Aletheya; 2001. 167 p.
235. Barth P. Fundamentals of semiology. In: Structuralism: pros and cons: Sat. Art. Moscow: Progress, 1975. P. 114–163.
236. Postmodernism: Encyclopedia. Minsk: Interpressservice; Book House; 2001. 1040 p.
237. Lévy-Bruhl L. Supernatural in primitive thinking. Moscow: NPedagogy-Press; 1994. 608 p.
238. Krasnykh VB, Gudkov DB, Zakharenko IV. Theoretical statements. Principles of description. Russian cultural space: Linguistic and cultural dictionary. Moscow: Gnosis; 2004. P. 7–56.
239. Troitsky VP. «As you name, so shall you doom» (Onomatodoxy in creative biography of Vyacheslav Ivanov). In: Vyacheslav Ivanov – Creativity and Fate: for the 135th Anniversary of Birthday. Moscow: Nauka; 2002. P. 81–87.
240. Ospovat A. Naming of the hero of «The Captain’s Daughter». In: Lotmanovsky collection. Moscow: OGI; 2003. P. 261–269.
241. Kiseleva L. To the formation of the concept of a national hero in Russian culture of the first third of the 19th century. In: Lotmanovsky collection. Moscow: OGI; 2003. P. 63–92.
242. Figurnova OS, comp. Anna Akhmatova in Duvakin’s notes. Moscow: Natalis; 1999. 368 p.
243. AB Azarkh-Granovskaya: conversations with VD Duvakin. Moscow; Jerusalem: Bridges of Culture; 2001. 200 p.
244. Bakhtin MM: conversations with VD Duvakin. Moscow: Consent; 2002. 400 p.
245. Makhlin VL. Also a conversation. Questions of literature. 2004;3:3–45.
246. Sadovnikov DN. Selected works. Saratov: Volga book publishing house; 1989. 224 p.
247. Goffman I. Frame analysis: an essay on the organization of everyday experience. Moscow: Institute of Sociology of the Russian Academy of Sciences; 2004. 752 p.
248. Zabudskaya YaL. Zionisism and tragedy: Aeschylus in translations by Vyacheslav Ivanova ). In: Vyacheslav Ivanov – Creativity and Fate: for the 135th Anniversary of Birthday. Moscow: Nauka; 2002. P. 141–147.
249. Time GA. Faces of Dionysianism (Vyach. Ivanov and G. Hauptmann). In: Proceedings of the Mater. international scientific conf. «Vyacheslav Ivanov – Petersburg – world culture». 9–11 September 2002. Tomsk – Moscow: Aquarius Publishers; 2003. P. 95–104.
250. Ivanov Vyach. Sporades. In: Ivanov Vyach. Collected works. Vol. 3. Brussels: Foyer Oriental Chretien;1979. P. 111–135.
251. Bonetskaya NK. Russian wanderers. Questions of philosophy. 2004;5:111–117.
252. Apinyan TA. A Game in a Serious Space. Game, Myth, Ritual, Dream, Art and Others. Saint Petersburg: St. Petersburg Publishing house; 2003. 400 p.
253. Kantor VK. The rise and fall of the era of artistry. Eves and milestones. Gips border epochs – types of border consciousness. In 2 parts. Part 2. P. 300–327.
254. Bychkova BB, ed. Lexicon of Nonclassics. Artistic and Aesthetic Culture of the Twentieth Century. Moscow: ROSSPEN; 2003. 607 p.
255. Bataille J. The Damned Share. Moscow: Gnosis; Logos; 2003. 208 p.
256. Molodyakov BE. Valery Bryusov: Political portrait. In: Valery Bryusov. World Competition: Political Commentary. 1902–1924. Moscow: AIRO-XX; 2003. 224 p.
257. Pushkin AS. The second volume of Polevoy’s «History of the Russian People». In: Pushkiv AS. Complete collection. In 10 volumes. Vol. 7: Criticism and journalism. Moscow – Leningrad: Publishing House of the USSR Academy of Sciences; 1949. P. 143–147.
258. Peko PF. Elements of Philosophy of Sciences. Moscow: Universal Library; 1915. 224 p.
259. Martishina NI. Cognitive Foundations of Parascience. Omsk: Omsk State Technical University Press; 1996. 187 p.
260. Dubnischeva TYa. Retrophysics in the Mirror of Philosophical Reflection. Moscow: INFRA-M; 1997. 334 p.
261. Soifer VN. Red Biology: Pseudoscience in USSR. Moscow: Moscow psychological-social Institute Press; 1998. 264 p.
262. Nizovtsev VV. Time and Place of 20th Century Physics. Moscow: Editorial URSS; 2000. 308 p.
263. Sokuler EA. Knowledge and Power: Science in Modern Society. Saint Petersburg: RKhGI; 2001. 240 p.
264. Bazylev VN, Neroznak VP, comp. and com. Twilight of linguistics. From the history of Russian linguistics. Anthology. Moscow: Academia; 2001. 576 p.
265. Behind the Iron Curtain: Myths and Realities of Soviet Science. Saint Petersburg: Dmitry Bulanin; 2002. 526 p.
266. Kara-Murza SG. Ideology and Its Mother Science. Moscow: Algorithm, 2002. 256 p.
267. Berg RL. Sukhovey: Memoirs of a geneticist. Moscow: Monuments historical thought; 2003. 527 p.
268. Izmailov IV, Poizner BN, Ravodin VO. Synergy, Competition, Chaos in the Model of Interaction between Two Scientific Directions. Tomsk: Tomsk State University Press; 2002. 100 p.
269. Alpatov VM. The Story of a Myth: Marr and Marrism. Moscow: Nauka; 1991. 240 p.
270. Allatov BM. Afterword to the Second Edition. In: Marr NYa. Japhetidology. Zhukovsky – Moscow: Kuchkovo pole; 2002. P. 475–478.
271. Ivanov Vyach. Sun. Odd and even. In: Ivanov Vyach. Sun. Favorite tr. in semiotics and cultural history. Vol. 1. Moscow: Languages of Russian culture; 1999. P. 381–604.
272. Avtonomova NA. Current past: structuralism and Eurasianism. In: Serio P. Structure and Integrity: On the Intellectual Origins of Structuralism in Central and Eastern Europe. 1920-30s. Moscow: Languages of Slavic culture; 2001. P. 9–30.
273. Serio P. Structure and Integrity: On Intellectual Origins Structuralism in Central and Eastern Europe. 1920-30s. Moscow: Languages Slavic culture; 2001. 360 p.
274. Korochkin LI. To the problems of biophilosophy: some general ones principles of organization and functioning of biological material. In: Baksansky OE, ed. Methodology of Biology: New Ideas (Synergetics, Semiotics, Coevolution). Moscow: Editorial URSS; 2001. P. 177–189.
275. Berg. RL. Lev Semenovich Berg. In: Berg RL. Sukhovey: Memories Genetics. Moscow: Monuments of historical thought, 2003. P. 431–440.
276. Poizner BN. From Prigogine to Aristotle: self-organization and entelechy. Journal of problems in the evolution of open systems. 2003;1(5):233–240.
277. Polozhiy AV. History of the formation of the concept of the species of higher plants. In: Stegnia VN, ed. Evolutionary biology. Tomsk: Tomsk State University Press; 2001. Vol. 1. P. 29–36.
278. Korochkin LI. Genes, Ontogeny and problems of evolutionary development. In: Stegnia VN, ed. Evolutionary biology. Tomsk: Tomsk State University Press; 2001. Vol. 1. P. 49–72.
279. Evgeniev MB, Zelentsova ES, Poluektova ES, Pyatkov KI. Invasion of mobile elements is the cause of explosive saltation speciation. In: Stegnia VN, ed. Evolutionary biology. Tomsk: Tomsk State University Press; 2001. Vol. 1. P. 37–48.
280. Melik-Gaykazyan IV. Information Processes and Reality. Moscow: Nauka; 1998. 192 p.
281. Chernavsky DS. Synergetics and Information. Dynamic Information Theory. Moscow: Nauka, 2001. 244 p.
282. Evdokimov EB, Shapovalov AB. Deterministic chaos in dynamics populations as an evolutionary factor. In: In: Stegnia VN, ed. Evolutionary biology. Tomsk: Tomsk State University Press; 2001. Vol. 1. P. 245–263.
283. Podlazov AB. Self-organized criticality and risk analysis. Izvestiya VUZ. Applied Nonlinear Dynamics. 2001;9(1):49–88.
284. Kibrik AE. Language constants and variables. Saint Petersburg: Aletheya; 2003. 720 p.
285. Ivanov Vyach. Roman diary of 1944. In: Ivanov Vyach. Collected works. Vol. 3. Brussels: Foyer Oriental Chretien;1979. P. 583–644.
286. Pavlenko AN. Theatre as an «optical device» of presentation. Human;2004:1:34–42.
287. Huizinga J. In the shadow of tomorrow. In: Huizinga J. Homo ludens. In the shadow of tomorrow. Moscow: Progress, Progress – Academy; 1992. P. 241–402.
288. Stepun FA. Thoughts about Russia. In: Stepun FA. Desired Russia. Saint Petersburg: RKhGI; 1999. P. 5–91.
289. Gorbanevsky M. Notes on the luminary. Literary newspaper. 1988;25(5):12.
290. Braginskaya NV. «...They have their own destiny». In: Freidenberg OM. Poetics Plot and Genre. Moscow: Labyrinth, 1997. P. 421–433.
291. Pocheptsov GG. Russian Semiotics. Moscow: Refl-book; Kyiv: Wakler; 2001. 768 p.
292. Bashinjagyan L. Memories of the future: Caucasian diary Lieutenant L.B. Independent newspaper. 1994. 8 September. P. 5.
293. Stalin IV. Regarding Marxism in linguistics. In: Marr NYa. Japhetidology. Zhukovsky – Moscow: Kuchkovo pole; 2002. P. 451–465.
294. Vitenberg BM. Towards Stalin. New lit. review. 2003;3(61):344–355.
295. Serebrennikov BA. Comparative historical method and criticism called four-element analysis NYa Marra. Questions of linguistics in the light of the works of IV Stalin: Lectures given to higher education teachers educational institutions in August 1950 at Moscow University. Moscow: Moscow State University; 1950. P. 171–186.
296. History and antihistory: Criticism of the «new chronology» of academician AT
Fomenko: Analysis of AT Fomenko’s answer. M.: Languages of Slavic Culture; 2001. 576 p.
297. Ilyin IP. Postmodernism: Dictionary of Terms. Moscow: INION RAS; Intrada; 2001. 384 p.
298. Kruglov AG. First Approximations: Dictionary of Aphorisms-definitions. Moscow: Gnosis; 1997. 128 p.
299. Dymerskaya L. Tomac Mann and Nikolai Berdyaev about spiritual and historical the origins of Bolshevism and National Socialism. Questions of Philosophy. 2001;5:62–77.
300. Kholin I. Poems and Poems. Moscow: New lit. review; 1999. 320 p.
301. Foucault M. Hermeneutics of the subject: A course of lectures at the College de France, 1982. Excerpts. Socio-Logos. 1991;1:284–312.
302. Popmu R. From religion through philosophy to literature: the path of the Western intellectuals. Voprosy filosofii. 2003;3:30–41.
303. Kufaev MN. Problems of Book Philosophy. The Book is in the Process of Communication. Moscow: Nauka; 2004. 188 p.
304. Petritsky BA. Social significance of bibliophilia. Book and Social Progress: Sat. Art. Moscow: Book; 1986. P. 71–78.
305. Rat MV. About Collecting. Moscow: New lit. review; 2002. 350 p.
306. Poizner BN. Hope for the correction of the world, books and bibliophilia. Current issues in the theory and history of bibliophilia. Saint Petersburg: Russian National Library Press; 2001. P. 20–24.
307. Rozanov VV. People of the moonlight: Metaphysics of Christianity. Saint Petersburg; 1913. 297 p.
308. Storch M, publ. From the correspondence of Gustav Shpet. Russian Thought. 1999; 4269:19.
309. Nefagina GL. Russian prose of the late twentieth century. Moscow: Flinta: Nauka; 2003. 320 p.
310. Schultz JrSS, Sklyarsky VA. Homeless Dog. Saint Petersburg: White and Chernoe; 2003. 206 p.
311. Caillois R. Man and the sacred. In: Caillois R. Myth and Man. Man and Sacred. Moscow: OGI; 2003. P. 141–291.
312. Paramonov B. Pushkin today (To the problem of multiculturalism). Zvezda. 2000;XXTU:6–12.
- 133 reads