For citation:
Poizner B. N. Charisma: replication of reception. Izvestiya VUZ. Applied Nonlinear Dynamics, 2004, vol. 12, iss. 3, pp. 84-109. DOI: 10.18500/0869-6632-2004-12-3-84-109
Charisma: replication of reception
Why the phenomenon of charisma deserves attention of social synergetics? How the sense of «charisma» concept has varied from antiquity up to now? What is a peculiarity of the charisma reception in Russian culture? How the midst of charismatic looks through the prism of nonlinear dynamics? The author aspires to answer similar questions proceeding from following thesis: propagation of the judgement about some person as а charismatic is typical case of а cultural pattern replication. The author bases on works on synergetics, theory of culture, sociology, linguistics, history of science, philosophical anthropology, examples of publicist style.
In first part of the paper a short description of charisma as a psychological phenomenon going back to the primeval society is done. Etymology of «charisma» concept is revealed, constants and variables of the concept sense are shown. It is
suggested to compare contexts in which the «charisma» concept is used in Christianity, Judaism, East philosophy. Semantic peculiarities of the «charisma» concept in Russian, French, English are discussed.
137. Khristoforova OB. Receiving a gift: stories about shamanism formation among the nganasans. World Tree. 2003;10:87–105.
138. Fedotov GP. In 12 vols. Vol. 8: Saints of Ancient Rus'. Moscow: Martis; 2000. 268 p.
139. Klimova SM. Phenomenology of holiness and passion in Russian philosophy of culture. Saint Petersburg: Aletheya, 2004. 329 p.
140. Struve NA. About A. Solzhenitsyn’s Harvard speech. In: Struve NA. Orthodoxy and Culture. Moscow: Russian way, 2000. P. 530–540.
141. Arnautova YuE. Sorcerers and Saints: The Anthropology of Disease in the Middle Ages century. St. Petersburg: Aletheya, 2004. 398 p.
142. Panchenko AM. Fools in Rus'. In: Panchenko AM. Russian History and Culture: Works from Different Years. Saint Petersburg: Yuna, 1999. P. 392–407.
143. Zaichenko AA. Foolishness. Materials of the interuniversity. Proceedings of the Scientific Conference «The ancient world and us». 22–24 May 2003, Saratov, Russia. Saratov: College, 2003. Vol. 9. P. 119–125.
144. Yangulova L. Foolish and Insane: Genealogy of Incarceration in Russia. Michel Foucault and Russia. Saint Petersburg; Moscow: European University in Saint Petersburg; Summer Garden; 2001. P. 192–212.
145. Mandelstam O. Sobr. op. In 4 vols. Vol. 3: Poetry and prose 1930–1937. Moscow: Art-Business Center; 1994. 528 p.
146. Faibisovich S. Russian new and non-new: Essay on the main thing. Moscow: New lit. review; 1999. 288 p.
147. Rovner А, ed. Mystics of the twentieth century. Encyclopedia. Moscow: Myth – Locked; 1996. 522 p.
148. Vasiliev S, comp. Encyclopedia of mystical terms. Moscow: Locked; Myth; 1998. 576 p.
149. Kirlezhev A. Church and world: paradox or synthesis? Russian thought. 2000;4324:19.
150. Rashkovsky EB. On the axis of time: Essays on the philosophy of history. Moscow: Progress-Tradition, 1999. 208 p.
151. Brudny AA. Personetics: project «Deep Raid». Moscow: Labyrinth; 2003. 256 p.
152. Buldakov VP. Red Trouble. The nature and consequences of revolutionary violence. Moscow: ROSSPEN; 1997. 376 p.
153. Dombrovsky T. Charisma. Saint Petersburg: Peter; 2002. 192 p.
154. Guseinov GCh. Soviet Ideologemes in Russian Discourse of the 1990s. Moscow: Three squares; 2004. 272 p.
155. Demonic charisma. NG` Ex libris. 31 October 2002. P. 6.
156. Garden «Buff». Tomsk. 28 November 2002. P. 16.
157. Sokolov A. Choice of three letters. Gomsky Bulletin: Regional daily newspaper. 15 March 2004. P. 1.
158. Chulkov G. Frank thoughts. Writers of the symbolist circle: New materials. 2003. P. 457–499.
159. Milk YuA. Pushkin in 1937. Moscow: New lit. review, 2000. 232 p.
160. Perelmutera V, comp. Pushkin in Exile. 1937. Moscow: Progress-Tradition, 1999. 800 p.
161. Gasparov ML. Centenary as Measure, or Classics in the background modernity. New lit. review. 2003;4 (62):13–14.
162. Perelmuter V. Pushkin’s Echo: Notes. Notes. Essay. Moscow; Toronto: The past – Library of Toronto Slavic Quarterly; 2003. 512 p.
163. Mak V. Israeli Prizes for Pierre Boulez and Riccardo Muti. Russian thought. 2000;4321:16.
164. Kremer G. Overtones. Moscow: Agraf; 2001. 352 p.
165. Zholkovsky AK. Erosipede and other vignettes. Tomsk – Moscow: Aquarius Publishers; 2003. 624 p.
166. Mazur NH. Pushkin and the «Moscow youths»: around problems of genius. In: Proceedings of the International Pushkin Conference. 12–17 April 1999. Stanford, California, USA: Stanford University Press, 2000. P. 54–105.
167. Paramonov B. Pushkin is our nothing. In: Paramonov B. Trace: Philosophy. Story. Modernity. Moscow: Nezavisimaya Gazeta, 2001. P. 411–424.
168. Matic O. Successful mafioso – dead mafioso: culture funeral rite. New literary review. 1998;5:75–107.
169. Ortega y Gasset H. Revolt of the masses. Questions philosophy. 1989; 3–4:117–138.
170. Voznesensky A, Lesin E. Charisma generated by action. NG Exlibris. 12 February 2004. P. 1.
171. Jung KG. Three interviews from the book «Jung Says... ». In: Jung KG, Samuels E, Odaynik V, Hubback J. Analytical Psychology. Moscow: Martis; 1995. P. 167–198.
172. Povartsov SN. Merezhkovsky, Wells and the red star. Questions literature. 2002;11–12:168–186.
173. Mirsky GI. Life in Three Eras. Moscow; Saint Petersburg: Summer Garden; 2001. 368 p.
174. Kaganovich LM. Memoirs. Moscow: Vagrius; 1996. 572 p.
175. Borev YuB. Staliniad. Moscow: Olympus, 2003. 461 p.
176. Prigogine N, Stengers I. Order from Chaos: New Human Dialogue with Nature. Moscow: Progress, 1986. 432 p.
177. Mednikov BM. Analogy (parallels between biological and cultural evolution. Man. 2004;1:5–17.
178. Sapir Ed. Communication. In: Sapir Ed. Selected Works on linguistics and cultural studies. Moscow: Progress-Univers, 1993. P. 210–215.
179. Khrenov N.A. Culture in an Era of Social Chaos. Moscow: Editorial URSS; 2002. 448 p.
180. Moss M. Body techniques. Man. 1993;2:64–79.
181. Bourdieu P. Structures, Habitus, Practices. In: Modern social theory: Bourdieu, Giddens, Habermas: Textbook. allowance. Novosibirsk: Novosibirsk University Press, 1995. P. 16–31.
182. Pelipenko AA. Genesis of semantic space and ontology culture. Man. 2002;2:6–21.
183. Savin M.G. Kulturon – a cosmic carrier of culture. Man. 2002;5:165–172.
184. Knabe GS. The second memory of Mnemosyne. Questions literature. 2004;1–2:3–24.
185. Rushkoff D. Media virus: How Pop Culture Secretly Affects your Consciousness. Moscow, 2003. 368 p.
186. Boym S. Commonplaces: The Mythology of Everyday Life. Moscow: New lit. review, 2002. 320 p.
187. Poizner BN., Sitnikova DL. Self-renewal of Culture and Synthesis Scientific Knowledge. Tomsk: Tomsk University Press; 2002. 184 p.
188. Vvedenova EI. Archetypes of the collective unconscious and problems formation of culture. In: Evolution. Language. Cognition. Moscow: Languages of Russian culture; 2000. P. 113–133.
189. Lotman YuM. Inside Thinking Worlds. Man – Semiosphere – History. Moscow: Languages of Russian Culture; 1996. 464 p.
190. Lotman YuM. Repeatability and Uniqueness in the Mechanism of Culture. In: Lotman YuM. History and Typology of Russian Culture. Saint Petersburg: Art-SPb; 2002. P. 67–70.
191. Laplanii J, Pontalis JB. Dictionary of Psychoanalysis. Moscow: Higher. School; 1996. 623 p.
192. Khoruzhy S.S. Man and his three distant destinies. New anthropology on based on ancient experience // Questions philosophy. 2003;1:38–62.
193. Rozov SM. Parvinism and epistemology: genetics and memetics. In: Materials for the history of the seminar MA Rozova on epistemology and philosophy «On the shadow side». Novosibirsk. Novosibirsk: NSU; 1996. P. 311–338.
194. Transmigration of Souls. Moscow: Golden Age; 1994. 426 p.
195. Yulen M. The idea of transmigration of souls in HHT B, or the Future of one illusion. Questions philosophy. 2003;3:49–61.
196. Zhidkov VS, Sokolov KB. Art and Picture of the World. Saint Petersburg: Aletheia; 2003. 464 p.
197. Tokarev DV. «Imagination is dead imagine»; Samuel Beckett’s «French» Prose. Beckett S. Worthless texts. Saint Petersburg: Nauka; 2001. P. 257–315.
198. Shpet GG. Literature. In: Shpet GG. History as a Problem of Logic. Critical and Methodological Studies. Materials. In two parts. Moscow: Monuments Historical Thought; 2002. P. 1133–1136.
199. Barantsev RG. Immanent Problems of Synergetics. In: New in Synergetics: View in the Third Millennium. M.: Nauka; 2002. P. 460–477.
200. Sosnin EA, Poizner BN. Workbook on Social Construction (Interdisciplinary Project). Part 2. Tomsk: Tomsk University; 2001. 132 p.
201. Pasternak BL. High disease. In: Pasternak BL. Poems and poems. Leningrad: Soviet writer; 1965. P. 236–244.
202. Poizner BN, Sitnikova DL. Big Bifurcation: the Birth of Mathematical Modeling. Izvestiya VUZ. Applied Nonlinear Dynamics. 2000;8(5):82–97.
203. Tolstoy LN. War and Peace. In 2 vols. Vol. 1. Moscow: Khudozh. Lit; 1978. 416 p.
204. Sosnin EA, Poizner BN. Social Virtuality. Tomsk: Tomsk University Press; 2002. 118 p.
205. Turchin VF. Phenomenon of Science: Cybernetic Approach to Evolution. Moscow: Science; 1993. 296 p.
206. Khaitun SD. The phenomenon of «redundancy» of the brain, genome and other developed organic and social structures. Questions philosophy. 2003;3:85–96.
207. Gellner E. Reason and Culture: The Historical role of Rationality and Rationalism. Moscow: Moscow school of political researches; 2003. 252 p.
208. Ivanov VV. Essays on Prehistory and History of Semiotics. In: Ivanov VV. Favorite tr. in semiotics and cultural history. Vol. 1. Moscow: Russian languages culture; 1999. P. 605–812.
209. Trubina EG, Kharitonov VV, editors. Metahistory: Historical Imagination in Europe of 19th Century. Ekaterinburg: Ural University Press; 2002. 528 p.
210. Ven P. Greeks and Mythology: Belief or Unbelief?: Experience of constitutive imagination. Moscow: Art; 2003. 224 p.
211. Ven P. How They Write history. Experience in Epistemology. Moscow: Scientific world; 2003. 394 p.
212. Rudakov VN. The Language of the Bible in the Early Stories of Russian Chronicles of Mongol-Tatar invasion. In: Gurevich Aja, ed. Odysseus: Man in history. Moscow: Nauka; 2003. P. 49–60.
213. Ankersmit FR. History and Tropology: the Rise and Fall of Metaphor. Moscow: Progress-Tradition; 2003. 496 p.
214. Aron P. Favorites: Dimensions of historical consciousness. Moscow: ROSSPEN; 2004. P. 7–176.
215. Bogdanov KA. Everyday life and mythology: Studies to semiotics of folklore reality. Saint Petersburg: Art-SPb; 2001. 438 p.
216. Hubner K. The Truth of Myth. M: Republic; 1996. 448 p.
217. Shklovsky VB. Art as a technique. In: Shklovsky VB. Hamburg check. Moscow, 1989. P. 58–72.
218. Poizner BN. On the synergetic dimension of art. Izvestiya VUZ. Applied Nonlinear Dynamics. 2001;9(6):168-189.
219. Poizner BN. The Replicator is an intermediary between man and history. Information from universities. Applied nonlinear dynamics. 1999;7(6):83–104.
220. Campbell J. The Hero with a Thousand Faces. Kyiv: Sofia; 1997. 336 p.
221. Jung KG. Soul and Myth: Six Archetypes. Kyiv: Ukrainian State Library for youth; 1996. 384 p.
222. Hayek FA. Society of the Free. London: OPI; 1990. 309 p.
223. Bloom H. Fear of Influence. Rereading Map. Ekaterinburg: Ural University Press; 1998. 352 p.
224. Podlazov AB. Theoretical demography. Models – growth population and global demographic transition. In: New Synergetics: A Look at the Third Millennium. Moscow: Nauka; 2002. P. 324–345.
225. Gromyko NYu. Sociocultural – diversity as a touchstone activity approach. Centaur. 2004;33:20–27.
226. Poizner BN. On the Incentives for the Formation of a Person and the Change of his values. Higher education in Russia. 1996;3:57–60.
227. Tilkes OK. Jewish time and space in Amsterdam. In:bIvanov VV. Remizov and Holland: Correspondence with BN Rapchinsky (1947–1957). Moscow: Nauka; 2004. P. 88–136.
228. Knabe GS. Thirst for Identity: Cultural and Anthropological Identification. Yesterday. Today. Tomorrow. Moscow: RSUH; 2003. 60 p.
229. Egorov BF. About provincial culture and regional identity (answers to questions from NV Serebrennikov). Siberia in the context of the world culture: Experience of self-description. Tomsk: Sibirika; 2003. P. 7 – 9.
230. Gennep A van. Rites of Passage. Systematic Study of Rituals. Moscow: Eastern literature; 1999. 198 p.
231. Turner V. Ritual process. Structure and antistructure. In: Turner V. Symbol and Ritual. Moscow: Nauka; 1983. P. 104–264.
232. Vereshchagin EM. Grace: chaotic space? In: Logical Analysis of the Language. Space and Chaos: Conceptual Fields of Order and Disorder. Moscow: Indrik; 2003. P. 32–40.
- 121 reads